Flash Posted Thursday at 01:14 Author Posted Thursday at 01:14 More info regarding yesterday's little "gulp" moment. I started off my pulling apart my mockup and then chucked a measuring tape on the M100 Sirion gearbag to check the distance between the centre of the input shaft and the gearbox casing where the right hand side CV joint resides. The magic number is somewhere between 130 and 133mm. Now looking at the schematic available for the ME1616 the overall physical dimensions of the casing are stated as 256mm. So taking a 256mm diameter this equates to a radius of 128mm which is damn close to the 130 to 133mm that I have available. In theory the motor should fit with a few millimeters to spare. However, the supplier cautions that the case is not prefectly circular. In addition to that we can't assume that there will be absolutely no sideways movement in a spiining CV joint that could quickly eat into the miniscule gap that we have available. Being a cautious fella I'm inclined to step away from the ME1616 as the motor of choice. So where does that leave us? Well, we could opt for the ME1905 which is the air cooled version of the ME1616. In swapping a few yarns with Brendon in Perth (the creator of the EV powered Moke using an A series gearbox) he reckons that over the almost 10 years that he has had his EV Moke on the road he has occasionally experienced thermal warning alarms especially in weather with temps of 30 degrees plus when the motor is working at higher speeds or loads. Based on Brendon's feedback I'd rather look for a liquid cooled alternative or a punchier air cooled option that fits the spacial constraints I am working with. More homework required. 3 Quote
Popular Post Flash Posted Friday at 08:46 Author Popular Post Posted Friday at 08:46 Spent a day on The Google looking at alternative liquid cooled motors. Everything from a Motenergy ME1302 through to a QS Motor 138V3, but all of them are way down on power compared to the ME1616. So at the end of the day I've decided to go with the ME1905. He being the air cooled equivalent of the ME1616 liquid cooled motor that I was previously going to use. I'm okay with the decision. As previously mentioned Brendon in Perth has used this setup in his EV Moke for almost 10 years now and is very happy with its performance. He has only had a few instances of thermal warnings when pushing the Moke hard on particularly warm days. Over time he has learnt to take things a bit easier in these conditions. I still think I can drastically improve the situation by fabricating up a shroud for the motor and setting up a forced air system using a high powered bilge pump that will duct cooler air in through the cooling fins on the motor casing. But that's something I can play with at a later stage. On the plus side I no longer need to faff about with small radiators, electric coolant pumps and a bunch of plumbing that the liquid cooled option entails. So with the final choice made I moved on to version 4 of the plywood mockup. First step was to create a much thicker adapter plate as this is needed to accomodate the longer output shaft on the ME1905 which measures an impressive 63.5mm long. According to my sums we will need an adapter plate of 30mm thick. So I made it so: I then carved out a new mockup motor based on the dimensions of the ME1905 and slapped it and the adapter plate onto the Sirion gearbag like so: As you can see she's pretty svelte. Before I chucked everything in the subframe I offered up the pesky right hand side inner CV joint to check clearances: Luverly ! Heaved it into position one more time and it's looking good: Checked clearances and there are a few tight spots. Spot 1: Back right corner of the subframe has a little ear that I can trim back to get enough clearance to keep cert man happy. Spot 2: Lip on the back of the subframe is close to the diff housing. Again a little nip and tuck should get us more clearance. Spot 3: This is looking up at the bottom of the subframe from underneath. The orange/ red pipe is the steering rack. I reckon I can "massage" that portion of the subframe to improve clearance by a tad. So yep, all in all not bad at all. Oh, and driveshaft alignment is pretty spot on. Okay so with that sorted I now need to focus on how I'm going to mount the gearbox/motor combo. The ME1905 tips the scales at 20.5kg and is face mounted to the aluminium adapter plate. That leaves the gearbag holding both the motor and itself in place. I also need to create a "shelf" above the motor/gearbox combo where I can mount the controller, the DC-DC converter, the Elcon TC charger and a few contactors and fuses and the like. So I'm thinking kill a few birds with one stone by creating a motor/gearbox cradle that will drop down into the subframe and will incorporate said shelf. In terms of mounting my cradle I've set my sights on the two upper subframe mounting points at the back of the subframe. This is the left hand side and is a twin of the right hand side: So the plan is to replace that crusty looking "3 holed" washer with a plate mount. As a first step I removed the fancy looking engine steady bar mount which revealed the mounting holes for brake and clutch master cylinders in a left hand drive version. I've got to cover those holes anyway, so I may as well use the extra mounting bolts to beef up the planned plate. Made a quick mockup using cardboard: The right hand side will look similar, but without the extra bit where my brake master cylinder bolts up. Then at the front of the cradle I'm going to pick up the left and right mounting points for the front bullbar that look like so: The white jobbies in the photo above. With the 4 corner plates mounted as planned, I'll then create the drop in cradle using 50x25x3 rectangular tube. There will be three cross tubes running left to right. First one just above the bullbar mounts. Next one at shelf height just above the motor and gearbox and the third one tucked up behind the upper plates again at shelf height. I'll then complete the box by running vertical tubes from each bullbar mount butted up against another tube at 90 degrees that will run backwards and attach to the rear of the cradle. This all makes sense in my head, but I'm not sure how it translates in this explanation. So forgive me if it sounds confusing. Anyway the cradle will pick up some gearbox mounts along the way that will hopefully hold everything in place. Here is a really bad photo showing a mockup bit of rectangular tube in place (the vertical bit I was talking about earlier): I'm not sure how clear it is on the photo, but there is a repurposed Toyota gearbox mount that I've bolted up to both the Sirion gearbox and the rectangular tube. Anyway, more cardboard aided design tomorrow to mock up the remaining 3 cradle mounting plates and then I need to figure out the placement of my additional gearbox mounts. Thanks heaps for reading. 9 2 Quote
Flash Posted yesterday at 01:51 Author Posted yesterday at 01:51 More cardboard aided design this morning. Started off with the right hand side upper mount for the cradle. Again using the upper subframe mount on this side. As can be seen in the photo I changed my mind and decided to incorporate the mounting area where the brake and clutch master cylinders attach. Reason being I'll no longer have a clutch master cylinder so I need to cover that hole anyway. Couldn't resist chucking my new dual circuit brake master cylinder in just to complete the overall look. I then sacrificed another cereal box to mock up the lower cradle mount: The other lower mount is a mirror image so I'll just turn the same template inside out when I cut that one. So with the cradle mounting brackets all mocked up I scratched through my shed to see what I had lying around materials wise. Gathered these bits together which I reckon will do the trick: Two old heat pump wall mounting brackets and a few old gate posts. All of them are thick walled stuff so perfect for my cradle. Bonus is that they have all been hot dipped galvanized. I'll use the two L brackets to make up the main bits of the cradle and the fence posts are perfect for the cross pieces. Here is another mockup of the horizontal bit of the cradle: I just clamped that piece of random tube in place to give you an idea of what I'm aiming for. So in real life those angled heat pump brackets will replace the random silver tube and the brownish coloured upright that you can see in the above photo. Okay with that all kinda worked out I turned my attention to the gearbox mounts. Yesterday I chucked in that Toyota Corolla gearbox mount that will be attached to the vertical portion of the heat pump angled bracket. So I need to come up with another mount for the opposite side of the gearbag. Rummaged amongst my stash one more time and found this gearbox mount from a Toyota HiAce. In HiAce land this single mount holds the entire gearbox in place. So I figure it is beefy enough for the task. Grovelled under the Moke and I think I have a cunning plan. I'll fabricate a little foot plate that I can glue to the bottom of the Moke subframe so the mount sits like so: And I'll then fabricate a U shaped bracket that will pickup 2 or 3 bolt holes around that lower corner of the bellhousing (the plywood sandwich that you can just see disappearing around the corner in the above photo). I'll check that cert man is happy before I go any further on the mounts. So that's kinda the cradle and gearbox mounts mocked up. Before I break out my grinder and welder I want to mockup the main battery cradle. So that's the plan for tomorrow morning. Thanks for looking. 8 Quote
Flash Posted 6 hours ago Author Posted 6 hours ago Okay battery cradle mockup day. Started off by creating a "to scale" version of one of the EVE LiFePO4 100Ah cells that I will be using: The pen in the photo shows just how tiny these cells are. 160mm on the long side, 50.1mm on the short side and the height shown is to the very top of the terminals being 135mm. I then cracked into the 12 cell cradle that will reside where the fuel tank used to go: Ended up looking like so: And birds eye view looks like so: There is space for 12 cells as indicated by the black lines. The 13th place is reserved for the compression plate which is needed to put the cells under pressure when stacked inside the cradle. Without compression the cells tend to bulge under heat and then delamination occurs within the cell which drastically shortens their lifespan. My initial plan for compression was to run two external M8 threaded rods down the mid point of each long side threaded through a fixed ear protruding on both short sides of the cradle. A compression plate is then installed inside the box with similar ears sticking through a slot carved into the side of the box. A nut on each threaded rod creates the needed compression. I actually mocked the compression mechanism up but when I offered the cradle up into the fuel tank recess the threaded rods wouldn't clear the surrounding lip in the Moke floor so I pulled everything apart in disgust before taking a photo. I've got a Plan B for the compression mechanism which I'll incorporate into this mockup at some stage. I finished off the morning by bolting the cradle in place using the original tank cover plate captive nuts. This is just temporary as I'll need to add beefier M10 bolts for the final cradle. The tank cover tucks in above the outer lip of the body and has captive nuts on that side of the cover. My box can't do that. My plan is to fabricate an inner plate with welded in nuts that will sandwich the thin body steel between the base of the cradle and my inner plate. It sounds over engineered, but according to the cert rules the battery cradle needs to be able to withstand a 20G force during a crash. I built the mockup using a 7mm ply for the base and 12mm ply for the walls. The inner dimensions are to scale, so the cradle is a little chunkier than it will be once built in 3mm steel plate. As a result the base plate looks a bit odd in this photo: And of course the side without the soon to be added captive nuts is hanging down which doesn't improve the look at all. But hey, its just a concept that I can use when I have my "show and tell" session with the cert man. So apart from the epic fail on the compression mechanism it looks like this cradle will work. My Plan A for the other side is to get the nod from cert man to cut out the floor of the 12 volt battery enclosure and the floor of the middle storage locker as well as the dividing wall between the two and then build a mirror image of the 12 cell cradle for that side. If cert man says no cutty cutty, then Plan B is to fabricate a total of 4 by 3 cell cradles that will be split across the two compartments. The reason they have to be 3 cell cradles is so that they are compact enough to go through the side opening on their sides and they then get rotated 90 degrees to the upright position and pushed forward and backward. Sounds confusing but here is a photo of the storage areas on that side which shows how tiny the openings are compared to the inside dimensions of each compartment: Current plan is to keep the front storage compartments in both pontoons for the high voltage isolation switches and fuses, but if I'm feeling energetic I might create another two by 2 cell cradles which will share some space in the front compartments. This will up my total cell count from 24 to 28 giving me a 16% increase in power and range. 28 cells will place me just below the upper limit of the Sevcon Gen 4 Size 6 controller that I will be using, but the increase in power and range might be worth the effort. Next step is to build mockups of the smaller cradles to see how these will work out. Thanks for looking. 5 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.